https://www.propel-legal.com/contactus 2026-08-22 https://www.propel-legal.com/privacy 2026-08-22 https://www.propel-legal.com/ https://www.propel-legal.com/blog https://www.propel-legal.com/blog/why-suing-openai-in-india-made-commercial-sense-for-ani-1 https://www.propel-legal.com/blog/the-delhi-high-court-refused-to-stop-openai-from-training-its-ai-at-the-interim-stage-but-if-ani-s-objective-was-to-protect-the-future-value-of-its-journalism-rather-than-win-the-first-hearing-filing-the-lawsuit-may-still-have-been-the-smartest-commercial-decision-it-could-make-the-common-perception-about-the-judgement-is-that-it-is-about-copyright-i-don-t-think-it-is-at-least-not-entirely-on-the-surface-the-dispute-appears-straightforward-ani-one-of-india-s-largest-news-agencies-accused-openai-of-using-its-news-content-without-permission-to-train-chatgpt-and-sought-an-interim-injunction-to-stop-further-use-the-delhi-high-court-however-refused-to-grant-that-immediate-relief-allowing-openai-to-continue-while-the-case-proceeds-to-trial-if-you-stop-reading-there-it-looks-like-a-simple-story-ani-sued-openai-won-the-first-round-case-closed-but-commercial-litigation-rarely-works-that-way-large-companies-do-not-spend-years-in-court-hire-senior-advocates-and-commit-significant-resources-merely-because-they-are-upset-behind-almost-every-major-intellectual-property-dispute-lies-a-much-bigger-commercial-objective-this-case-is-no-different-openai-was-represented-by-senior-advocate-amit-sibal-one-of-india-s-leading-arguing-counsel-on-ip-commercial-matters-if-you-look-closely-at-openai-s-strategy-it-was-never-trying-to-convince-the-court-that-copyright-had-become-irrelevant-in-the-age-of-artificial-intelligence-that-would-have-been-an-extremely-difficult-position-to-defend-instead-the-arguments-were-framed-much-more-narrowly-by-keeping-the-court-s-attention-on-the-limited-scope-of-interim-relief-and-on-the-concept-of-prima-facie-fair-dealing-openai-avoided-turning-the-hearing-into-a-philosophical-debate-about-whether-ai-should-exist-or-whether-copyright-law-needs-to-be-rewritten-to-understand-why-ani-went-to-court-you-have-to-stop-looking-at-this-as-a-copyright-dispute-and-start-looking-at-it-as-a-battle-over-the-future-economics-of-information-imagine-you-own-the-only-well-in-a-village-imagine-you-own-the-only-well-in-a-village-for-years-people-have-come-to-your-well-every-morning-because-it-is-the-only-reliable-source-of-water-you-spend-money-maintaining-it-keeping-it-clean-and-ensuring-that-it-never-runs-dry-in-return-people-pay-for-access-and-that-is-how-your-business-survives-one-day-someone-studies-your-well-understands-exactly-where-the-underground-water-flows-and-digs-another-well-nearby-they-haven-t-taken-your-land-they-haven-t-broken-your-well-in-fact-your-well-is-still-exactly-where-it-has-always-been-but-something-important-has-changed-people-no-longer-need-to-come-to-you-your-asset-hasn-t-disappeared-its-commercial-value-has-that-in-many-ways-captures-the-concern-behind-ani-s-lawsuit-ani-doesn-t-sell-news-it-sells-access-to-news-a-layman-may-think-ani-s-business-is-writing-news-articles-but-it-is-not-its-real-business-is-collecting-reliable-information-before-anyone-else-does-and-licensing-that-information-to-newspapers-television-channels-websites-and-digital-platforms-every-day-ani-spends-money-sending-reporters-into-the-field-verifying-facts-interviewing-sources-and-covering-events-across-the-country-those-activities-are-expensive-but-they-create-something-valuable-trusted-information-the-commercial-value-of-ani-s-business-lies-not-merely-in-owning-the-words-printed-in-an-article-it-lies-in-being-the-source-from-which-others-obtain-news-for-decades-that-business-model-made-perfect-sense-then-artificial-intelligence-arrived-openai-changed-the-rules-of-the-game-suppose-you-ask-chatgpt-what-happened-in-parliament-today-you-are-no-longer-necessarily-visiting-a-newspaper-s-website-you-may-never-see-the-advertisements-that-fund-journalism-you-may-never-purchase-a-subscription-you-may-never-know-which-news-organisation-originally-invested-the-time-and-money-to-collect-that-information-from-ani-s-perspective-that-changes-the-economics-of-journalism-its-concern-was-not-simply-that-openai-had-used-its-articles-during-the-training-of-an-ai-model-the-bigger-concern-was-that-ai-systems-could-eventually-become-an-alternative-destination-for-millions-of-readers-reducing-the-commercial-value-of-the-very-content-on-which-those-systems-were-trained-the-lawsuit-therefore-was-asking-a-much-larger-question-can-an-ai-company-build-enormous-commercial-value-by-learning-from-content-that-someone-else-spent-years-and-millions-of-rupees-creating-that-is-not-merely-a-legal-question-it-is-a-business-question-think-about-what-happened-to-taxi-drivers-when-uber-entered-the-market-it-did-not-manufacture-cars-it-built-technology-that-connected-passengers-with-drivers-more-efficiently-than-traditional-taxi-operators-the-value-shifted-passengers-still-wanted-transportation-they-simply-no-longer-relied-on-the-old-system-to-obtain-it-artificial-intelligence-presents-a-similar-challenge-for-businesses-built-around-information-people-still-want-answers-they-may-simply-stop-relying-on-traditional-publishers-to-obtain-them-that-possibility-is-exactly-what-companies-like-ani-are-trying-to-address-so-why-didn-t-the-court-stop-openai-because-courts-do-not-decide-cases-based-on-commercial-anxiety-they-decide-them-based-on-legal-principles-and-evidence-at-the-interim-stage-the-delhi-high-court-was-not-deciding-who-would-ultimately-win-the-lawsuit-it-was-deciding-whether-openai-s-activities-should-be-stopped-immediately-while-the-case-continues-the-court-was-not-persuaded-that-such-an-extraordinary-order-was-justified-at-this-stage-that-does-not-mean-ani-s-concerns-are-imaginary-nor-does-it-mean-openai-has-won-the-case-it-simply-means-the-court-was-not-convinced-that-an-immediate-injunction-was-appropriate-before-the-issues-are-fully-examined-that-distinction-is-important-because-interim-hearings-are-often-about-preserving-the-status-quo-not-delivering-the-final-answer-then-why-sue-at-all-this-is-where-many-people-misunderstand-commercial-litigation-businesses-do-not-file-important-lawsuits-only-when-they-are-certain-of-victory-sometimes-they-file-them-because-remaining-silent-would-be-even-more-expensive-imagine-you-own-a-company-whose-most-valuable-asset-is-intellectual-property-if-someone-begins-using-that-intellectual-property-in-a-way-that-could-permanently-reduce-its-commercial-value-doing-nothing-sends-a-dangerous-signal-customers-notice-competitors-notice-investors-notice-future-negotiating-partners-notice-by-filing-the-lawsuit-ani-achieved-something-that-has-nothing-to-do-with-winning-an-interim-injunction-it-told-the-market-that-our-journalism-is-an-asset-and-we-intend-to-protect-it-that-message-matters-because-intellectual-property-is-valuable-only-if-its-owner-is-willing-to-defend-it-litigation-can-be-a-business-strategy-founders-often-think-of-litigation-as-a-cost-sometimes-it-is-but-sophisticated-businesses-often-view-litigation-as-an-investment-a-lawsuit-can-achieve-objectives-that-extend-far-beyond-the-courtroom-it-can-encourage-future-licensing-negotiations-it-can-establish-that-the-company-takes-its-intellectual-property-seriously-it-can-reassure-shareholders-that-valuable-assets-are-being-protected-it-can-even-influence-how-future-laws-develop-in-emerging-industries-the-courtroom-is-only-one-place-where-commercial-disputes-are-fought-the-market-is-another-the-real-war-isn-t-ani-vs-openai-the-real-conflict-is-between-two-entirely-different-economic-models-one-model-says-that-those-who-invest-in-creating-original-content-should-continue-to-control-how-that-content-generates-commercial-value-the-other-argues-that-technological-innovation-depends-upon-the-freedom-to-learn-from-publicly-available-information-and-transform-that-learning-into-new-products-neither-position-is-irrational-both-have-enormous-economic-consequences-that-is-why-this-dispute-has-attracted-global-attention-because-whichever-model-ultimately-prevails-will-influence-not-only-journalism-but-also-publishing-software-development-education-entertainment-and-every-industry-whose-primary-asset-is-knowledge-the-lesson-for-every-founder-whenever-technology-changes-the-way-customers-access-your-product-your-intellectual-property-strategy-must-change-with-it-that-is-precisely-why-ani-sued-openai-the-interim-injunction-may-have-been-refused-but-if-the-objective-was-to-protect-the-long-term-value-of-its-business-shape-the-legal-conversation-around-ai-and-copyright-and-signal-to-the-market-that-its-content-is-worth-defending-then-the-lawsuit-was-far-more-than-a-legal-action-it-was-a-commercial-strategy-and-that-is-why-every-founder-every-publisher-and-every-owner-of-intellectual-property-should-pay-close-attention-to-what-happens-next-if-you-wish-to-read-the-whole-200-page-judgement-of-the-delhi-high-court-dm-me-and-i-ll-send-you-the-pdf-it-is-the-first-judgement-on-india-s-ai-jurisprudence-and-worth-reading-2 https://www.propel-legal.com/blog/https-www-linkedin-com-pulse-can-using-pirated-software-really-send-director-civil-priyam-k-vlcrc-3 https://www.propel-legal.com/blog/the-delhi-high-court-refused-to-stop-openai-from-training-its-ai-at-the-interim-stage-but-if-ani-s-objective-was-to-protect-the-future-value-of-its-journalism-rather-than-win-the-first-hearing-filing-the-lawsuit-may-still-have-been-the-smartest-commercial-decision-it-could-make-the-common-perception-about-the-judgement-is-that-it-is-about-copyright-i-don-t-think-it-is-at-least-not-entirely-on-the-surface-the-dispute-appears-straightforward-ani-one-of-india-s-largest-news-agencies-accused-openai-of-using-its-news-content-without-permission-to-train-chatgpt-and-sought-an-interim-injunction-to-stop-further-use-the-delhi-high-court-however-refused-to-grant-that-immediate-relief-allowing-openai-to-continue-while-the-case-proceeds-to-trial-if-you-stop-reading-there-it-looks-like-a-simple-story-ani-sued-openai-won-the-first-round-case-closed-but-commercial-litigation-rarely-works-that-way-large-companies-do-not-spend-years-in-court-hire-senior-advocates-and-commit-significant-resources-merely-because-they-are-upset-behind-almost-every-major-intellectual-property-dispute-lies-a-much-bigger-commercial-objective-this-case-is-no-different-openai-was-represented-by-senior-advocate-amit-sibal-one-of-india-s-leading-arguing-counsel-on-ip-commercial-matters-if-you-look-closely-at-openai-s-strategy-it-was-never-trying-to-convince-the-court-that-copyright-had-become-irrelevant-in-the-age-of-artificial-intelligence-that-would-have-been-an-extremely-difficult-position-to-defend-instead-the-arguments-were-framed-much-more-narrowly-by-keeping-the-court-s-attention-on-the-limited-scope-of-interim-relief-and-on-the-concept-of-prima-facie-fair-dealing-openai-avoided-turning-the-hearing-into-a-philosophical-debate-about-whether-ai-should-exist-or-whether-copyright-law-needs-to-be-rewritten-to-understand-why-ani-went-to-court-you-have-to-stop-looking-at-this-as-a-copyright-dispute-and-start-looking-at-it-as-a-battle-over-the-future-economics-of-information-imagine-you-own-the-only-well-in-a-village-imagine-you-own-the-only-well-in-a-village-for-years-people-have-come-to-your-well-every-morning-because-it-is-the-only-reliable-source-of-water-you-spend-money-maintaining-it-keeping-it-clean-and-ensuring-that-it-never-runs-dry-in-return-people-pay-for-access-and-that-is-how-your-business-survives-one-day-someone-studies-your-well-understands-exactly-where-the-underground-water-flows-and-digs-another-well-nearby-they-haven-t-taken-your-land-they-haven-t-broken-your-well-in-fact-your-well-is-still-exactly-where-it-has-always-been-but-something-important-has-changed-people-no-longer-need-to-come-to-you-your-asset-hasn-t-disappeared-its-commercial-value-has-that-in-many-ways-captures-the-concern-behind-ani-s-lawsuit-ani-doesn-t-sell-news-it-sells-access-to-news-a-layman-may-think-ani-s-business-is-writing-news-articles-but-it-is-not-its-real-business-is-collecting-reliable-information-before-anyone-else-does-and-licensing-that-information-to-newspapers-television-channels-websites-and-digital-platforms-every-day-ani-spends-money-sending-reporters-into-the-field-verifying-facts-interviewing-sources-and-covering-events-across-the-country-those-activities-are-expensive-but-they-create-something-valuable-trusted-information-the-commercial-value-of-ani-s-business-lies-not-merely-in-owning-the-words-printed-in-an-article-it-lies-in-being-the-source-from-which-others-obtain-news-for-decades-that-business-model-made-perfect-sense-then-artificial-intelligence-arrived-openai-changed-the-rules-of-the-game-suppose-you-ask-chatgpt-what-happened-in-parliament-today-you-are-no-longer-necessarily-visiting-a-newspaper-s-website-you-may-never-see-the-advertisements-that-fund-journalism-you-may-never-purchase-a-subscription-you-may-never-know-which-news-organisation-originally-invested-the-time-and-money-to-collect-that-information-from-ani-s-perspective-that-changes-the-economics-of-journalism-its-concern-was-not-simply-that-openai-had-used-its-articles-during-the-training-of-an-ai-model-the-bigger-concern-was-that-ai-systems-could-eventually-become-an-alternative-destination-for-millions-of-readers-reducing-the-commercial-value-of-the-very-content-on-which-those-systems-were-trained-the-lawsuit-therefore-was-asking-a-much-larger-question-can-an-ai-company-build-enormous-commercial-value-by-learning-from-content-that-someone-else-spent-years-and-millions-of-rupees-creating-that-is-not-merely-a-legal-question-it-is-a-business-question-think-about-what-happened-to-taxi-drivers-when-uber-entered-the-market-it-did-not-manufacture-cars-it-built-technology-that-connected-passengers-with-drivers-more-efficiently-than-traditional-taxi-operators-the-value-shifted-passengers-still-wanted-transportation-they-simply-no-longer-relied-on-the-old-system-to-obtain-it-artificial-intelligence-presents-a-similar-challenge-for-businesses-built-around-information-people-still-want-answers-they-may-simply-stop-relying-on-traditional-publishers-to-obtain-them-that-possibility-is-exactly-what-companies-like-ani-are-trying-to-address-so-why-didn-t-the-court-stop-openai-because-courts-do-not-decide-cases-based-on-commercial-anxiety-they-decide-them-based-on-legal-principles-and-evidence-at-the-interim-stage-the-delhi-high-court-was-not-deciding-who-would-ultimately-win-the-lawsuit-it-was-deciding-whether-openai-s-activities-should-be-stopped-immediately-while-the-case-continues-the-court-was-not-persuaded-that-such-an-extraordinary-order-was-justified-at-this-stage-that-does-not-mean-ani-s-concerns-are-imaginary-nor-does-it-mean-openai-has-won-the-case-it-simply-means-the-court-was-not-convinced-that-an-immediate-injunction-was-appropriate-before-the-issues-are-fully-examined-that-distinction-is-important-because-interim-hearings-are-often-about-preserving-the-status-quo-not-delivering-the-final-answer-then-why-sue-at-all-this-is-where-many-people-misunderstand-commercial-litigation-businesses-do-not-file-important-lawsuits-only-when-they-are-certain-of-victory-sometimes-they-file-them-because-remaining-silent-would-be-even-more-expensive-imagine-you-own-a-company-whose-most-valuable-asset-is-intellectual-property-if-someone-begins-using-that-intellectual-property-in-a-way-that-could-permanently-reduce-its-commercial-value-doing-nothing-sends-a-dangerous-signal-customers-notice-competitors-notice-investors-notice-future-negotiating-partners-notice-by-filing-the-lawsuit-ani-achieved-something-that-has-nothing-to-do-with-winning-an-interim-injunction-it-told-the-market-that-our-journalism-is-an-asset-and-we-intend-to-protect-it-that-message-matters-because-intellectual-property-is-valuable-only-if-its-owner-is-willing-to-defend-it-litigation-can-be-a-business-strategy-founders-often-think-of-litigation-as-a-cost-sometimes-it-is-but-sophisticated-businesses-often-view-litigation-as-an-investment-a-lawsuit-can-achieve-objectives-that-extend-far-beyond-the-courtroom-it-can-encourage-future-licensing-negotiations-it-can-establish-that-the-company-takes-its-intellectual-property-seriously-it-can-reassure-shareholders-that-valuable-assets-are-being-protected-it-can-even-influence-how-future-laws-develop-in-emerging-industries-the-courtroom-is-only-one-place-where-commercial-disputes-are-fought-the-market-is-another-the-real-war-isn-t-ani-vs-openai-the-real-conflict-is-between-two-entirely-different-economic-models-one-model-says-that-those-who-invest-in-creating-original-content-should-continue-to-control-how-that-content-generates-commercial-value-the-other-argues-that-technological-innovation-depends-upon-the-freedom-to-learn-from-publicly-available-information-and-transform-that-learning-into-new-products-neither-position-is-irrational-both-have-enormous-economic-consequences-that-is-why-this-dispute-has-attracted-global-attention-because-whichever-model-ultimately-prevails-will-influence-not-only-journalism-but-also-publishing-software-development-education-entertainment-and-every-industry-whose-primary-asset-is-knowledge-the-lesson-for-every-founder-whenever-technology-changes-the-way-customers-access-your-product-your-intellectual-property-strategy-must-change-with-it-that-is-precisely-why-ani-sued-openai-the-interim-injunction-may-have-been-refused-but-if-the-objective-was-to-protect-the-long-term-value-of-its-business-shape-the-legal-conversation-around-ai-and-copyright-and-signal-to-the-market-that-its-content-is-worth-defending-then-the-lawsuit-was-far-more-than-a-legal-action-it-was-a-commercial-strategy-and-that-is-why-every-founder-every-publisher-and-every-owner-of-intellectual-property-should-pay-close-attention-to-what-happens-next-if-you-wish-to-read-the-whole-200-page-judgement-of-the-delhi-high-court-dm-me-and-i-ll-send-you-the-pdf-it-is-the-first-judgement-on-india-s-ai-jurisprudence-and-worth-reading-2/feed https://www.propel-legal.com/blog/why-suing-openai-in-india-made-commercial-sense-for-ani-1/feed https://www.propel-legal.com/blog/https-www-linkedin-com-pulse-can-using-pirated-software-really-send-director-civil-priyam-k-vlcrc-3/feed